Ice Cream — Mitchell's Homemade

//--Google Analytics

Ice Cream, Friends
& Community

We handcraft our ice creams one small batch at a time, using local dairy and fresh seasonal ingredients.

Click Here for All Ingredients & Allergen Information

Flavors

Banana Cream Pie

INGREDIENTS:
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic bananas, Stutzman Farms’ organic wheat flour, Organic butter (Organic cream, Salt), Organic tapioca syrup and/ or corn syrup, Organic eggs, Natural flavor, Kosher fish gelatin (parve), Sea salt, Ascorbic acid (anti-oxidant vitamin C), Organic carob bean gum, Baking Soda.
CONTAINS: Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Fish
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, and soy.

Blue Cosmo™

INGREDIENTS:
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic eggs, Organic tapioca syrup and/ or corn syrup, Natural & artificial flavor, Kosher fish gelatin (parve), Sea salt, Blue 1, Organic carob bean gum.
CONTAINS: Eggs, Milk, Fish
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, and soy.

Caramel Sea Salt

INGREDIENTS:
Cream, Skim milk, Organic fair-trade sugar, Brown cane sugar, Sweetened condensed milk (Milk, Sugar), Organic tapioca syrup, Organic butter (Organic cream, Salt), Sea salt, Natural vanilla flavor, Organic carob bean gum, Baking soda.
CONTAINS: Milk
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, eggs, soy, wheat, and fish gelatin.

Coffee Chocolate Chunk

INGREDIENTS:
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Fair-trade dark chocolate (Sugar, Alkalized chocolate liquor, Cocoa butter, Milkfat, Sunflower lecithin, Vanilla), Fair-trade Arabica coffee, Sumatran coffee, Organic egg yolks, Organic soy oil, Organic carob bean gum.
CONTAINS: Eggs, Milk, Soy
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, and fish gelatin.

Dark Roast Coffee

INGREDIENTS
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Fair-trade Arabica coffee, Sumatran coffee, Organic egg yolks, Organic carob bean gum.

CONTAINS: Eggs, Milk
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, soy, wheat, and fish gelatin.

Bing Cherry Chocolate Chunk

INGREDIENTS:
Skim milk, Cream, Bing cherries and juice, Organic fair-trade sugar, Fair-trade dark chocolate (Sugar, Alkalized chocolate liquor, Cocoa butter, Milkfat, Sunflower lecithin, Vanilla), Organic soy oil, Cane sugar, Natural flavor, Organic carob bean gum.
CONTAINS: Milk, Soy
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, eggs, wheat, and fish gelatin.

Butter Pecan

INGREDIENTS:
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, roasted pecans [Pecans, Peanut oil or sunflower oil, Salt, Butter (Cream, Salt)], Sweetened condensed milk (Milk, Sugar), Organic tapioca syrup, Organic butter (Organic cream, Salt), Natural flavor, Salt, Organic carob bean gum, Baking soda.
CONTAINS: Pecans, Peanuts, Milk
May contain traces of eggs, soy, wheat, fish gelatin, and various tree nuts.

Chocolate

INGREDIENTS:
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic fair-trade alkalized cocoa, Organic egg yolks, Organic carob bean gum.
CONTAINS: Eggs, Milk
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, soy, wheat, and fish gelatin.

Cookie Dough

INGREDIENTS:
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Stutzman Farms’ organic wheat flour, Fair-trade non-GMO chocolate chips (Sugar, Unsweetened chocolate, Cocoa butter, Dextrose, Sunflower lecithin), Organic butter (Organic cream, Salt), Pasteurized organic eggs, Natural vanilla flavor and beans, Organic tapioca starch, Sea salt, Organic carob bean gum.
CONTAINS: Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Soy
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, and fish gelatin.

Double Chocolate Chunk

INGREDIENTS
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Fair-trade dark chocolate (Sugar, Alkalized chocolate liquor, Cocoa butter, Milkfat, Sunflower lecithin, Vanilla), Organic fair-trade alkalized cocoa, Organic egg yolks, Organic soy oil, Organic carob bean gum.

CONTAINS: Eggs, Milk, Soy
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, and fish gelatin.

Black Raspberry Chocolate Chunk

Black Raspberry Chocolate Chunk

INGREDIENTS:
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Black raspberries, Fair-trade dark chocolate (Sugar, Alkalized chocolate liquor, Cocoa butter, Milkfat, Sunflower lecithin, Vanilla), Organic soy oil, Citric acid, Organic carob bean gum.
CONTAINS: Milk, Soy
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, eggs, wheat, and fish gelatin.

Caramel Fudge Brownie

INGREDIENTS:
Cream, Skim milk, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic eggs, Organic butter (Organic cream, Lactic acid), Organic fair-trade alkalized cocoa, Stutzman Farms’ organic wheat flour, Sweetened condensed milk (Milk, Sugar), Organic tapioca syrup, Natural vanilla flavor and beans, Sea salt, Organic carob bean, Baking soda.
CONTAINS: Wheat, Eggs, Milk
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, soy, and fish gelatin.

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

INGREDIENTS:
Skim Milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Peanut butter cups (Sugar, Coconut oil, Peanuts, Skim milk, Milk, Alkalized cocoa, Salt, Soy lecithin, Natural flavors), Roasted peanuts, Organic fair-trade alkalized cocoa, Salt, Organic carob bean gum.
CONTAINS: Coconut, Peanuts, Milk, Soy
May contain traces of eggs, wheat, fish gelatin, and various tree nuts.

Cookies & Cream

INGREDIENTS:
Skim milk, Cream, Oreo Cookies [Enriched wheat flour (Wheat Flour, Niacin, Reduced Iron, Thiamine mononitrate, Riboflavin, Folic acid), Sugar, Palm and/or canola oil, Alkalized Cocoa, Invert sugar, Leavening (Baking soda and/or calcium phosphate), Soy lecithin, Salt, Chocolate, Natural flavors], Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic egg yolks, Natural vanilla flavor and beans, Organic carob bean gum.
CONTAINS: Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Soy
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, and fish gelatin.

Fresh Mint Chocolate Chunk

INGREDIENTS
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Fair-trade dark chocolate (Sugar, Alkalized chocolate liquor, Cocoa butter, Milkfat, Sunflower lecithin, Vanilla), Organic egg yolks, Organic soy oil, Organic fresh peppermint, Natural flavor, Organic carob bean gum.
CONTAINS: Eggs, Milk, Soy
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, and fish gelatin.

Fresh Strawberry

INGREDIENTS
Skim milk, Cream, Strawberries, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic egg yolks, Organic carob bean gum.
CONTAINS: Eggs, Milk
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, soy, wheat, and fish gelatin.

Key Lime Pie

INGREDIENTS
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Key lime juice, Organic butter (Organic cream, Salt), Stutzman Farms’ organic whole wheat flour, Organic egg yolks, Organic carob bean gum.
CONTAINS: Wheat, Eggs, Milk
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, soy, and fish gelatin.

Pralines & Cream

INGREDIENTS
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Praline pecans [Sugar, Pecans, Butter (Cream, Salt), Natural flavor, Corn syrup, Salt], Organic egg yolks, Sweetened condensed milk (Milk, Sugar), Organic tapioca syrup, Organic butter (Organic cream, Salt), Natural vanilla flavor and beans, Sea salt, Organic carob bean gum, Baking soda.
CONTAINS: Pecans, Eggs, Milk
May contain traces of peanuts, soy, wheat, fish gelatin, and various tree nuts.

Toasted Pistachio

INGREDIENTS
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Toasted pistachios, Organic egg yolks, Natural flavor, Salt, Organic carob bean gum.
CONTAINS: Pistachios, Eggs, Milk
May contain traces of peanuts, soy, wheat, fish gelatin, and various tree nuts.

Wildberry Crumble

INGREDIENTS
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic blueberries, Black raspberries, Red raspberries, Stutzman Farms’ organic wheat flour and organic oats, Organic butter (Organic cream, Salt), Organic egg yolks, Natural vanilla flavor and beans, Cinnamon, Pectin, Citric acid, Organic carob bean gum.
CONTAINS: Wheat, Eggs, Milk
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, soy, and fish gelatin.

Vanilla Bean

INGREDIENTS
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic egg yolks, Vanilla extract and beans, Natural flavor, Organic carob bean gum.
CONTAINS: Eggs, Milk
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, soy, wheat, and fish gelatin.

Vegan Salted Caramel Pecan

INGREDIENTS
Coconut milk (contains xanthan & guar gum), Organic fair-trade sugar, Filtered water, Ground toasted pecans, Brown cane sugar, Sea salt, Natural vanilla flavor.
CONTAINS: Pecans, Coconut
May contain traces of peanuts, milk, eggs, soy, wheat, fish gelatin, and various tree nuts.

Vegan Chocolate

INGREDIENTS
Coconut milk (contains xanthan & guar gum), Organic fair-trade sugar, Fair-trade dark chocolate (Chocolate liquor, Sugar, Sunflower lecithin, Vanilla), Filtered water, Organic soy lecithin.
CONTAINS: Coconut, Soy
May contain traces of peanuts, milk, eggs, wheat, fish gelatin, and various tree nuts.

Mango Sorbet

INGREDIENTS
Alphonso mangoes, Filtered water, Organic fair-trade sugar.
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, milk, eggs, soy, wheat, and fish gelatin.

Raspberry Sorbet

INGREDIENTS
Red raspberries, Filtered water, Organic fair-trade sugar.
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, milk, eggs, soy, wheat, and fish gelatin.

Lemon Black Raspberry Yogurt

INGREDIENTS
Skim milk, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic lemon juice, Corn syrup, Black raspberries, Cream, Sweetened condensed milk (Milk, Sugar), Pure lemon extract, Organic carob bean gum, Pectin, Citric acid, Live yogurt cultures.
CONTAINS: Milk
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, eggs, soy, wheat, and fish gelatin.

Peanut Butter Chocolate Pretzel Yogurt

INGREDIENTS
Skim milk, Pretzel pieces {Pretzels [Enriched wheat flour (contains Iron, Niacin, Thiamine mononitrate, Riboflavin, Folic acid), Canola oil, Salt, Malted Barley Syrup, Yeast, Baking Soda], Sugar, Coconut oil, Nonfat milk, Milk, Alkalized cocoa, Cocoa, Soy lecithin, Natural flavors}, Corn syrup, Organic fair-trade sugar, Roasted peanuts, Cream, Salt, Organic carob bean gum, Live yogurt culture.
CONTAINS: Wheat, Peanuts, Milk, Soy
May contain traces of tree nuts, eggs, and fish gelatin.

Seasonal Flavors

Cinnamon

INGREDIENTS
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Organic egg yolks, Vietnamese cinnamon, Natural flavor, Organic carob bean gum.
CONTAINS: Eggs, Milk
May contain traces of tree nuts, peanuts, soy, wheat, and fish gelatin.

Peppermint Stick

INGREDIENTS
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Peppermint candy [Sugar, Corn syrup, Palm Kernel Oil (contains soy lecithin) Natural red vegetable juice coloring, Coconut oil, Peppermint oil], Organic egg yolks, Fresh peppermint, Natural flavor, Organic carob bean gum
CONTAINS: Coconut, Eggs, Milk, Soy
May contain traces of peanuts, wheat, fish gelatin, and various tree nuts.

Amaretto Cookie

INGREDIENTS
Skim milk, Cream, Organic fair-trade sugar, Stutzman Farms' organic wheat flour, Organic butter (Organic cream, Salt), Ohio honey, Toasted pistachios, Natural flavor, Organic carob bean gum, Baking soda, Salt
CONTAINS: Pistachios, Wheat, Milk
May contain traces of peanuts, eggs, soy, fish gelatin and various tree nuts.

Turtle Brownie

INGREDIENTS
Cream, Skim milk, Organic fair-trade sugar, Roasted pecans [Pecans, Peanut oil, Salt, Butter (Cream, Salt)], Organic fair-trade alkalized cocoa, Organic eggs, Organic butter (Organic cream, Salt), Stutzman Farms' organic wheat flour, Sweetened condensed milk (Milk, sugar), Organic tapioca syrup, Brown cane sugar, Natural vanilla flavor, Salt, Organic carob bean gum, Baking soda
CONTAINS: Pecans, Wheat, Peanuts, Eggs, Milk
May contain traces of soy, fish gelatin, and various tree nuts.

Vegan Chocolate Mint Truffle

INGREDIENTS
Coconut milk (contains xanthan & guar gum), Organic fair-trade sugar, Fair-trade dark chocolate (Chocolate liquor, Sugar, Sunflower or Soy lecithin, Vanilla), Filtered water, Organic soy oil, Peppermint extract, Organic soy lecithin.
CONTAINS: Coconut, Soy
May contain traces of peanuts, milk, eggs, wheat, fish gelatin, and various tree nuts.

Vegan Buckeye

INGREDIENTS
Filtered water, Coconut milk (contains xanthan & guar gum), Organic fair-trade sugar, Roasted peanuts, Organic chocolate (Organic chocolate liquor, Organic sugar, Organic cocoa butter, Organic soy lecithin, Organic vanilla), Organic fair-trade alkalized cocoa, Organic tapioca syrup, Salt, Natural vanilla flavor.
CONTAINS: Coconut, Peanuts, Soy
May contain traces of milk, eggs, wheat, fish gelatin, and various tree nuts.

Specialties

M&P_Favorites.png

Mike & Pete’s
Favorites